The former NFL star and his wife are already parents to daughters Wyatt, Elliotte and Bennett

Jason and Kylie Kelce just announced that they are expecting another girl!

The former NFL star, 36, and his wife, 32, announced they are expecting their fourth child and fourth daughter in a Instagram post on Friday, November 22.

“I think we captured a very accurate representation of how each of the girls feels about having another sister,” a pregnant Kylie wrote in the Instagram caption. “At least Ellie, Mom and Dad are on the same page! “

The couple are already parents to three girls: Wyatt, 5, Elliotte, 3, and Bennett, 21 months. In the adorable snapshot, each girl donned matching sweaters with “big sister” embroidered on them.

The three girls show a range of emotions, with Wyatt watching in disbelief as she cups her hands to her head. Elliotte smiles broadly at the camera and Bennett cries.

Never miss a story – sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to keep you updated on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Several Instagram users flooded the comments to celebrate the family’s news – including the grandmother Donna Kelce. The proud grandmother of three wrote, ” Love it!!!”

The official account for Jason and Travis Kelce’s podcast, New heightswrote: Congratulations to the whole family .” While the Philadelphia Eagles simply commented, “Congratulations .”

Brittany Mahomes also wrote a celebrity message: “Ahhhhhh Congratulations!!! .”

“It’s an ‘I just became a middle child!'” cry, one user jokingly wrote. “Jason is the ultimate girl dad,” added another user.

One user commented, “All girls soccer teams in the near future maybe?”

Family: Jason Kelce Teases Idea of ​​Baby No. 4 With Wife Kylie Kelce: ‘We’ll Find Out’ (Exclusive)

In July 2024, Jason opened up about the possibility of having a fourth child with his wife when he spoke to PEOPLE at the American Century Championship presented by American Century Investments in Lake Tahoe.

“It’s not my decision,” Jason told PEOPLE. “We’ve talked about, before we had kids, having certain numbers but I think whatever Kylie is comfortable with.”

“We’ll figure it out,” adds the former Philadelphia Eagles star, regarding the parents who are already outnumbered by their children.

The PEOPLE Puzzler Crossword is here! How fast can you solve it? Play now!

Jason’s comment came just days after his wife Kylie also hinted at the possibility to have a fourth child.

“We’re going through clothes we bought for our first daughter now for our youngest, so we’ve been going through a lot of hand-me-downs,” Kylie shared New York Magazine website The Strategist.

“… Hanna Anderson PJs last forever. We still have some packed, just in case there’s a fourth,” added the mother of three. “It’s the best investment.”